Summary: Suncor Energy and Cenovus Energy, both prominent players in the Canadian energy industry, have similar portfolios consisting of oil sand/heavy oil production facilities and downstream refinery capacity. However, they differ in terms of market capitalization, safety and operational issues, production capacity, valuation, dividends, and record of returns. While Suncor has a larger market capitalization, it has struggled with safety and operational challenges in recent years and has consistently underperformed expectations. On the other hand, Cenovus, although slightly smaller in size, has demonstrated better capital allocation, balance sheet management, and overall financial performance. Cenovus has also shown higher returns in both the short and long term. Moreover, Suncor offers a higher dividend yield compared to Cenovus. Considering the operational and financial aspects, Cenovus appears to be a more favorable investment option at present.
Suncor Energy, with a market capitalization of $59 billion, operates a variety of assets including in situ production plants, oil sands mines, offshore rigs, refineries, and fuel wholesale/retail outlets across Canada and the U.S. It produces approximately 750,000 BOE/d and refines around 550,000 barrels per day. However, Suncor has encountered safety and operational issues in recent years, leading to underperformance compared to expectations. The company has been looking to acquire the right assets to backstop its energy reserves but has been unsuccessful thus far.
Cenovus Energy, with a market capitalization of $52 billion, primarily derives its energy production from oil sands, but also has a significant portion from conventional and offshore resources. It expects to produce approximately 785,000 BOE/d and refine 745,000 barrels per day by 2023. Cenovus has also faced challenges, such as a fire at one of its refineries. However, the refinery is operational again and expected to contribute to earnings in the latter half of the year.
In terms of valuation, Suncor stock has a lower price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio and price-to-free cash flow (P/FCF) compared to Cenovus. Suncor currently carries a higher net debt of $14 billion, while Cenovus has a lower net debt of $6.4 billion. Additionally, the dividend yield is higher for Suncor at 4.5% compared to Cenovus’ 2%. However, Cenovus has been growing its dividend at a faster rate and has even paid a special dividend in the past.
When considering the record of returns, Cenovus has significantly outperformed Suncor in both the short and long term. Over the past three and five years, Cenovus has delivered returns of 338% and 138%, respectively, while Suncor has returned 186% and 9%. This superior track record is attributed to Cenovus’ more thoughtful approach to capital allocation and balance sheet management, as well as its ability to generate higher levels of free cash flow, leading to more significant share buybacks, dividend growth, and overall returns.
In conclusion, while Suncor Energy is a well-known name in the Canadian energy industry, Cenovus Energy appears to be the more favorable investment choice at present. Cenovus has demonstrated better operational and financial performance, outperforming Suncor in terms of returns. With its prudent capital allocation and stronger balance sheet, Cenovus is positioned to provide investors with attractive investment opportunities in the energy sector.
Definitions:
– Market capitalization: The total value of a company’s outstanding shares of stock, calculated by multiplying the share price by the number of shares outstanding.
– Oil sands: Naturally occurring mixtures of sand, clay, water, and bitumen (a heavy and viscous form of oil). Oil sands are a primary source of unconventional oil.
– Downstream: Refers to the stages of the oil and gas industry that involve refining and processing crude oil and natural gas into marketable products, such as gasoline, diesel, and various chemicals.
Sources: No URLs provided.